MY MONEY
Minister Kasaija, Muhakanizi To Know Their Fate Over Shs727Bn PTA Loan Today
Published
7 years agoon
By Stella Mugoya: Minister of Finance, Planning and Economic Development Matia Kasaija along with the Secretary to Treasury, Keith Muhakanizi are set to know their fate over misappropriation of over Shs720M meant to purchase drugs for National Medical Stores (NMS) today.
The decision will follow a debate on the floor of Parliament following an investigation carried out by the Public Accounts Committee (PAC) that recommended the firing of the Ministry’s top officials. An investigation conducted by PAC, led by Angeline Osegge (Soroti Woman MP), into the acquisition and utilisation of the USD200M approximately Shs727,832,761,440 loan (at current exchange rate), uncovered evidence that revealed that although the funds were received by the Ministry, the intended beneficiary NMS didn’t receive the funds.
Despite the fact that the report had been completed in August 2017, it didn’t feature on the Parliament order paper until the report came up for presentation in January 2018.
Top among the recommendations was the call to have Kasaija censured. “For misleading the House to believe that the most critical funding objective was medical supplies, lying to Parliament in writing that NMS had never provided the needed supply contracts to enable disbursment of funds and further duping Parliament by re-packaging the same loan thus obtaining money by false pretense, the Minister of Finance Matia Kasaija must be censured,” the report read in part.
However, after the report was presented, Kasaija, who had earlier been described as a “hostile witness” after he declined to appear before PAC during the investigations, asked the Deputy Speaker, Jacob Oulanyah to allow him present his evidence before a decision on the matter is taken. Kasaija begged, “I want to be given an opportunity in this matter to explain. I would like Parliament to create good time for me to bring all the evidence, facts and where I have faulted I will apologize, I’m sure I have done what I ought to have done. Therefore, I would request that you give me an opportunity to give my response.”
Oulanyah obliged to Kasaija’s pleas and allowed him to present his evidence, plenary sitting was adjourned up to 30th January 2018, when the matter is expected to come up for discussion again.
On the other hand, it wasn’t only Kasaija that put up a spirited defence over the accusations labeled against him, but Muhakanizi too filed his defence.
For Muhakanizi, his sins come after it was discovered that he lied to the Committee that the loan was acquired for purposes of stabilising the exchange rate with the approval of Bank of Uganda, a claim the Central Bank vehemently denied as false.
Muhakanizi who was a former Chairman of the Board of Directors of the PTA Bank is accused of acting out of selfish interest, by insisting on acquiring the loan despite objections from the Central Bank Governor and the Accountant General, who protested against the loan arguing that the loan was not favourable because of its high interest rate.
Yet with all the accusations and calls to have him relieved of his duties, Muhakanizi scoffed at his tormentors during a media briefing at the Ministry headquarters on 16th January 2018, saying he isn’t going anywhere.
“I see a number of you make a statement that I am about to be sacked because of the PTA Bank loan. I can assure you I have a contract I will serve it up to the end. Take it from me because I accounted publicly in the papers for all the resources,” Muhakanizi bragged. He explained that the funds in contention were borrowed legally and the whole process passed through the same Parliament that has now turned around to investigate him, arguing he released as per appropriation of Parliament, to all the entities. The Secretary to the Treasury added, “And therefore, I am as clean as I can be. So, all those who have speculated that I am about to go, I am here. It is just wastage of your time, just concentrate on what you are doing. I am here as Secretary of Treasury for some time.” Ahead of the debate on the matter, Kasaija called for backup from his NRM counterparts during a caucus meeting at Office of the Prime Minister, but his pleas fell on deaf ears as many told him to pay for his own sins, with most of them arguing that the time to shield Government officials implicated in corruption had elapsed.
Glance Into PTA Loan Fracas
The funds were a loan acquired from the Eastern and Southern African Trade and Development Bank (PTA). The Finance Ministry tabled a request to borrow the funds on 3rd March 2016 with the Ministry arguing that the money was meant to finance development expenditure imports and replace part of the high interest domestic borrowing on 3rd March 2016.
Although Parliament rejected the loan proposal on 7th January 2016, with the Parliament Committee on National Economy, that was charged with processing the loan stating that Uganda is a member of the International Monetary Fund and is required to borrow to boost government reserves to finance shortfalls in the Balance of Payments if there is an urgent B.O.P deficit needed.
In the circumstance however, Parliament found no urgency with the loan request since at the time (December 2015), Uganda’s reserves were worth 3.9 months of imports and this did not demonstrate any urgency to Uganda as its import cover is above 3 months of the import cover benchmark of the IMF, Parliament said while rejecting the loan proposal.
Parliament’s decision to reject the loan followed a warning by the Central Bank Governor who wrote to the Minister of Finance on 2nd February 2016, objecting to the loan noting that the primary motivation for contracting the PTA loan was to stabilize the exchange rate in the face of temporary shocks, yet Balance of Payment were not purely temporary. In his recommendations, the Governor said that given the fact that Bank of Uganda had more than sufficient foreign exchange reserves to support these interventions; with the reserves in the Bank coffers at the time amounting to USD2.8Million and therefore did not require additional resources mobilised from the PTA Bank, and more so a loan.
The Ministry of Finance however bounced back again and presented the same loan proposal for the second time on 6th April 2016, but this time around, the title of the proposal had been changed and highlighted that the loan was intended to provide medical supplies by NMS. The Ministry of Ministry of Works and Transport and Rural Electrification Agency were the other intended beneficiaries and the loan was approved by Parliament on the 26th April 2016 with signing of the loan agreement on 26th June 2016.
It wasn’t long before National Medical Stores requested for USD68Billion after suffering numerous budget cuts and severe depreciation of the shilling against the dollar. And on 30th November 2015, Muhakanizi admitted the funding constraints and told NMS that the loan was being processed by Parliament, although by The situation continued to get out of hand and by 10th May 2016,
NMS hadn’t received a penny and reminded Muhakanizi of the USD68Million supplementary budget. This time around, Muhakanizi said the money would be provided in the FY 2016/2017 and went on to demand NMS to submit procurement contracts for items with foreign currency requirements for FY 2016/2017, a request NMS abided with.
In a letter dated 27th April 2017 to the Minister of Health, copied to NMS, the Minister of Finance stated that a sum of Shs7Billion had been provided as a supplementary in 2016/2017 and that Shs20Billion had been provided to NMS as arrears in 2017/2018. This time around, the Secretary to Treasury cautioned NMS should get medicines on credit worth Shs41Billion.
According to the Committee investigations, Muhakanizi’s letter stating that Shs41Billion will be availed in the next FY2016/2017 was a confirmation that the money had not been given to NMS, despite the loan having been received by Government.
Now, the Committee has called to have the USD200Million be recovered, re-consolidated to NMS to be used for purchase of medical supplies.
Comments
You may like
MY MONEY
Kampala City Traders Boss Kabanda In Deep Trouble For Mismanaging Money Members Contributed To Fight EFRIS…
Published
16 hours agoon
September 9, 2024Kampala city traders associations members under their umbrella body the Federation of Uganda Traders Association (FUTA) have tasked their controversial chairperson John Kabanda to give them accountability for the funds they contributed to run federation activities.
Isaac Kauma, a member of Kampala Traders Association, exclusively revealed to theGrapevine that Kabanda turned furious and started spreading malicious propaganda against a section of traders who are demanding for accountability of their money which they have been contributing since last year.
Kauma narrated that when President Museveni confirmed that he was going meet them again on 18th July, 2024 at Kololo Airstrip ground to further discuss their grievances over the controversial Electronic Fiscal Receipting and Invoicing Solution (EFRIS), Kabanda and other FUTA leaders approached traders and asked them to contribute money which they were going to use to transport traders from all corners of the country to fill the entire venue to show the president that they have the numbers and the capacity.
He added that Kabanda confirmed to them that they need numbers to out compete members of the Kampala City Traders Association (KACITA) who wanted to show the president that they are the ones controlling traders after accusing KACITA leadership of betraying them and by being in bed with Uganda Revenue Authority (URA) which was imposing EFRIS on them.
Kauma asserted that more than 1000 traders around Kampala city contributed between Shs10,000-Shs20,000 but the meeting didn’t take place because the venue was under renovation and the president promised to meet them on another date.
He said that State House made the said announcement after Kabanda and other traders’ leaders met Museveni at State House Entebbe and they were told that Kabanda and his deputy chairperson Godfrey Katongole asked the president for a private meeting with him which the president accepted.
Kauma added that they later learnt that Kabanda and Katongole asked the President to give them Shs3bn to mobilize traders to accept EFRIS a proposal the president declined to accept.
The President told them that he doesn’t the money they were asking for but promised to put Shs300m in their SACCO.
“From that day, Kabanda’s behavior is questionable, he always doesn’t want to be asked questions on why the president is not meeting us and turns furious when asked to give us accountability for the money we contributed for the function which didn’t take place,” Kauma said.
He revealed that the accountability issue has weakened the federation thus causing a sharp fight between Kabanda and Katongole.
Other traders allege that Kabanda has fired Katongole from being his vice chairperson and removed him from their WhatsApp group and replaced him with Moses Lwegaba the chairperson of Katukazane Shoe Dealers Association.
Sources claim that Katongole supporters are now threatening to take action against Kabanda for firing the man who has done everything in the struggle to fight for traders and replaced him with a newcomer.
Insiders are now alleging that the two leaders are fighting over a bribe they received during the EFRIS strike when traders closed their shops.
There is another allegation that Katongole was given money to go to the Eastern part of the country and mobilize traders to join the strike but he refused to go and decided to hide in Kampala.
When he was put under pressure to provide evidence that he traveled upcountry and had none, he was shown the exit.
When contacted, Kabanda confirmed the infighting, explaining that it is aimed at weakening his FUTA leadership and the trust that the traders have placed in them.
He revealed that even though he is receiving threatening messages, his resolve is still strong and he is ready to fight for all traders.
He denied allegations of mismanaging traders’ money.
By Timothy Nyanzi
Comments
CRIME
ABSA Bank Dragged To Court For Stealing Dead Customer’s Money…
Published
3 weeks agoon
August 21, 2024Eunice Nabadda Kayondo the Administrator of the Estate of the late Dan Kayondo has dragged ABSA bank to the High Court Civil Division Kampala over allegations of stealing money for the dead.
Nabadda through her lawyers led by Ronald Ruhinda claims that she is a daughter to Kayondo who was also given powers by court to administer his Estate including the bank account number 0288045860 which is in ABSA Bank Luwum Street Branch in Kampala city.
In her affidavit, she told court that after securing the powers of administering her father’s bank account, she went to the bank and the bank’s managers verified and approved her documents declaring her as the single signatory of the said bank account.
She narrated that the bank took all the necessary requirements including her telephone number which was going to be used for subsequent notifications and alerts.
She added that she found Shs40m on her father’s bank account.
She divulged that since the day she took over the account, she has never withdrawn any money, but she was surprised to learn that the account had only Shs3m as outstanding balance recently.
She insists that the bank breached the confidence she entrusted them with and slept on the job thus she wants court to compel them to pay her for the damage they caused.
“The plaintiff shall aver and contend that the acts and omissions of the defendants (bank) affected the Estate adversely and shall seek general damages of Ug Shs100, 000, 000,” the lawyers stated in their plaint.
Nabadda added that because of the bank’s actions, she suffered great loss and mental anguish for which she wants court to award her special damages.
She further wants court to order the bank to return Shs40m that was removed from her bank account without her knowledge.
However, the bank through their lawyers led by David Mpanga denied all the allegations insisting that they were not aware of the said fraud.
By Sengooba Alirabaki
Comments
MY MONEY
Inside Equity Bank, Dei Pharmaceuticals Tycoon Magoola Fresh Legal Fight Over Shs578bn Bailout From M7 Government …
Published
4 weeks agoon
August 13, 2024Dr. Mathias Magoola together with his companies Dei Industries International Limited and Dei Biopharma limited formally Dei Natural Products International industries limited has institute a commercial suit in the High Court Commercial Division accuses Equity bank Uganda and Kenya of fraudulently scheming to target the money given to him by President Yoweri Kaguta Museveni’s government to settle his financial troubles and save his companies.
A few months back, parliament approved Shs578bn to be given to Magoola as bailout to his companies which were facing financial hardships with banks threatening to auction his properties which he used as security.
However, through his lawyers led by commercial law giant Fred Muwema, Magoola alleges that when the bank got information that government had bailed him out, it started inflating his loan balance of with the mission of taking all the money given to him by government.
He wants court to declare that the bank’s demand dated 27th June, 2024 both in US dollars and shillings for the payment of the outstanding loan was illegal.
He explain to court that in 2016, he entered into a banker-customer relationship with equity bank and he applied for and obtained a credit facility of Shs400m to finance the completion of the construction of his factory at Kyadondo Block 82, plot 3228 Kiryamuli.
He continued obtaining several loans in subsequent years from the same financial institution.
He notes that all the credit facilities he obtained from equity bank contained a clause which encouraged him to seek independent legal advice in order to understand all the terms and conditions of the loan he was receiving.
He explains that despite the said clause, the bank officers were overbearing in their advice to him to take the loans as offered owing to the cordial relationship between the parties and thus he took their advice and signed the credit offer letters without consulting external legal lawyers.
He pins Samuel Kirubi, a manager at equity bank Uganda, Jimmy Mwangagi the Head of Credit, Munywa the Head of Risk, Abel Musiime the Head of Trade and Finance and Edward Ocen the legal officer of the bank for having guided and advised him when signing the loan transaction papers.
He adds that he was compelled to take the said loans, variation of terms, consolidations and restructures as offered because he was in urgent need of money to finance his capital-intensive projects.
Magoola accuses the bank officers of placing him in a tight spot with real threats of default foreclosure of his businesses which left him with no option but to accede to the bank’s demands.
He claims that counsel John Kabandize whose signature was seen on the signed documents as his lawyer was merely a witness to the agreement.
He explained to court that his companies faced hardship in servicing the loans due to unforeseen circumstances like Covid-19 outbreak and the Russian-Ukraine war which affected wheat imports for one of his companies dealing in import of wheat.
These hardships forced him to close it three years back.
He added that the delays in the completion of his medical plant also affected his plans of servicing his loans which resulted into high interest repayments to more than Shs150bn.
“That the defendants who are in a dominant bargaining position took advantage of the plaintiff’s desperation to engage in predatory lending practice done in violation of his non-delegable fiduciary and statutory duties,” he stated.
Magoola informed court that he reach out to the bank’s managers pleading with them to be reasonable in their demands.
He first requested for a waiver of exorbitant loan interests, then he asked to settle the outstanding loan that was at the tune of Shs155,188,727,733.
When all his prayers were rejected by the bank, which insisted on receiving full payment of the outstanding loan as demanded, he hired a certified public accounting firm to review the credit facilities and loan statements so as to determine the correct outstanding loan.
The firm issued an initial preliminary report which after full examination of the few loan statements availed, revealed that the banks had inflated the loan outstanding claim by a sum of Shs39,241,743,163.
He decided to inform the bank in writing.
Based on the explanation to court, Magoola and his companies prayed to court to issue an order for an account audit and reconciliation of the loan and the current accounts his companies held with the said banks to determine his actual debt, variation of terms, loan consolidations and also restructure it.
He also wants the court to issue a court order directing the banks to credit the plaintiff’s loan or current accounts with any amount of money found to be unlawfully debited upon the taking of an account, audit and reconciliation.
He wants court to also direct the bank to refund Shs47,652,951,120 which was unlawfully debited from his loan accounts and also declare that that the interest deducted during moratorium period for credit facilities on account No. 2220578883978 and 2220580311116 amounting to US$4,331,424 was illegal explaining that it denied him cash flow and caused loss and damages to his projects.
Magoola wants a declaration that the receipt, withholding and transfer of his US$9m loan repayment by equity bank Uganda to equity bank Kenya was an arbitrary act which exposes him to unnecessary penalty interest for which the defendants are liable to refund.
He insists that during the transfer of his money, they charged him Shs1,045,000,000 as interest which he says was an unlawful. He wants the funds to be returned.
He notes that the conversion of his US$2.430m credit facility to Shs11.5bn denied him liquidity and resulted in exchange loss to the tune of US$42,750 which the defendants are liable to refund.
The debiting of Shs80,000,000 as a loan processing fee for variation of terms and loan restructures in the credit facility of Shs16bn was extortionate and unconscionable.
He further wants the court to declare that the bank’s predatory lending practices resulted in a breach of the bank’s fiduciary and statutory duties owed to him.
The banks have not yet filed their defense so that the matter can kickoff.
By Sengooba Alirabaki
Comments
Bobi Wine Declines To Meet Troubled MP Luumu Concerning His Amendment Involving Electing LoP…
Kampala City Traders Boss Kabanda In Deep Trouble For Mismanaging Money Members Contributed To Fight EFRIS…
Top City Tycoons, UETCL Bosses In Trouble Over Shs28.8bn Illegal Compensation Deal…
Pressure On MP Ssemujju Mounts As M7’s NRM And Bobi Wine’s NUP Plot To Kick Him Out Of Kira Municipality…
NRM Top Boss Asks IGP Byakagaba To Kick-Out New Bean Weevils In Police Force As CID, DPP Bosses Send Last Warning To Violent Politicians…
MP Nambooze Narrates Why Former Legislator Kasibante Is Fighting Bobi Wine…
Chinese Company Directed To Destroy Plastic Products For Infringing On Ugandan Businessman’s Product Design…
Top Lawyer Supports High Court Judge Wamala On Katanga Land Dispute Over Powers Of State House Official…
INSIDE STORY: How M7 Fused Journalist Serwanjja’s Arrest As Intelligence zeroes On Two American Organisations On Allegation Of Funding Kampala Unrests….
M7’s Top Minister, City Lawyers Face Arrest Over Fraudulent US$250,000,000 Fertilizer Deal – Police…
Inside Equity Bank, Dei Pharmaceuticals Tycoon Magoola Fresh Legal Fight Over Shs578bn Bailout From M7 Government …
M7 Succession Battle Resurrects As Top Political Expert Weighs In On Gen Muhoozi, Rwabwogo War Of Words….
Panic At City Hall As Brig Isoke’s Boys Raid KCCA Directors’ Offices And Politicians Offices Over Corruption Allegations…
Why Mirundi Cursed Mukono Legislator Nambooze To Run Mad…
Buganda Clan Heads Boxed In Corner After Kabaka Mutebi Gives Orders To BLB On Managing Ancestral Clan Land…
Musician Nubian Lee Orders Wife Out Of Politics: Bobi Wine Plans To Front Him For Nakawa Division Mayor Seat…
PHOTOS: What You Missed At Zzina Carnival
PHOTOS: Golola Squeezes Babe @Club Tavern Kick, Tycoon Lwasa Slaughters Ten Goats To Rally Drivers And Fans
Drunk Chameleon Beats Up Journalist Seguya At Kusasira Introduction: No More Divorce – Kusasira Swears
DJ Michael Parades Hot Bikini Babes In New Video Shoot
What You Missed At Gudlyfe’s ‘10 Years Of Radio And Weasel’
Grapevine Babe: Denise Umwaruke
Nantaba defects to togikwatako, Forced to wear red ribbon
Singer fails to account for 20M Condolence from State House. Blamed for using it on Zuena’s Baby Shower
like us
TRENDING
- NATIONAL1 month ago
Untold Story: Who Is Threatening Kabaka Mutebi’s Throne! Fight For His Successor Deepens…
- CELEBRITY GOSSIP1 month ago
Tycoon BMK Empire Falling Apart After Minister Balaam Floors Fallen Businessman’s Son In Shs1.4bn Case…
- NATIONAL3 weeks ago
INSIDE STORY: How M7 Fused Journalist Serwanjja’s Arrest As Intelligence zeroes On Two American Organisations On Allegation Of Funding Kampala Unrests….
- CELEBRITY GOSSIP1 month ago
City Lawyer Mbidde Financial Woes Deepen As Bank Threatens To Auction His Hotel Over Debt…
- NATIONAL1 month ago
Kabaka Mutebi Lawyers In Panic After Court Sets Timeline On Prayer To Allow His Subject To Access His Bank Accounts, Classified Agreements Signed With M7 And Land Titles…
- CRIME2 months ago
City Businessman In Tears After Wife Abandons Him And Marries Fellow Rich Woman In Finland…
- CELEBRITY GOSSIP1 month ago
Lawyer Moogi Secures Breathing Space For Tycoon Bitature After ABSA Bank, UETCL Had Threaten To Auction His Multibillion Properties Over Electro-Maxx Deal…
- CRIME2 months ago
Senior Prosecutor In DPP’s Office Charged In Court For Stealing M7 Portrait…
Leave a Reply